Investigation number
AO-2011-042
Occurrence date
Location
East Wallabi Island
State
Western Australia
Report release date
Report status
Final
Investigation level
Short
Investigation type
Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status
Completed
Aviation occurrence category
Collision with terrain
Occurrence class
Accident
Highest injury level
Minor

On 25 March 2011, a Cessna 172 aircraft, registered VH-SMY, departed Geraldton on a charter passenger flight to East Wallabi Island (in the Abrolhos Islands group), Western Australia.

While on final approach to the Island, the nose of the aircraft was positioned at a 45° angle to the runway to remain aligned with the centreline due to gusty winds. The wind conditions appeared to be from an east to south-easterly direction. When at about 500 ft the pilot elected to overfly the runway.

A second approach was commenced, but the wind was again too strong for a landing with a go-around conducted. Despite full power being applied the engine did not perform as expected during the climb for another circuit.

During downwind, the pilot noted that the windsock was moving considerably. On final, the aircraft was again at a 45° angle and experiencing wind buffet.

During the landing flare, the aircraft floated, before touching down about halfway along the runway. Determining the aircraft could not be stopped by the runway end, the pilot elected to go-around. He moved the throttle full forward, but the engine did not deliver full power. The aircraft momentarily became airborne before contacting a sand dune and coming to rest upright in the water.

The pilot reported that, due to the recent commencement of his employment with the operator, he wanted to complete the flight.

This accident highlights the need for pilots to be aware that self-imposed undue pressure, can come about for a variety of reasons (time or task-oriented). It is important to understand one's personal limitations, especially when flying in or around adverse weather conditions.

Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
Cessna Aircraft Company
Model
172
Registration
VH-SMY
Serial number
172 70657
Operation type
Charter
Sector
Piston
Departure point
Geraldton, WA
Destination
Big Pigeon Island, WA
Damage
Substantial