Collision with terrain, 2 km west of Esperance Aerodrome, Western Australia, on 26 May 2007, VH-FTT, Piper PA28RT-201

Summary

On 26 May 2007 at about 1644 Western Standard Time, a Piper Aircraft Corp PA-28RT-201 aircraft, registered VH-FTT, departed Jandakot Airport for Esperance, WA. On board the private, visual flight rules (VFR) flight were the non-instrument-rated owner-pilot, and two passenger friends.

The flight arrived at Esperance about 1 hour and 40 minutes after last light, and in marginal weather conditions. The aircraft impacted the ground on what appeared to be a right base for runway 11. There were no survivors.

There was no evidence of any technical defect or other failure of the aeroplane, or of its associated systems, prior to the impact with terrain. That, and the normal operation of the approach and landing aids, and apparent activation of the aerodrome lighting, suggested that the most likely factors that contributed to the development of the occurrence related to the operation of the aircraft.

The investigation was unable to conclusively establish the reason for the impact with terrain. The investigation could not exclude the possibility of a sudden incapacitation of the pilot due to a cardiac condition. However, the weather conditions enroute to, and in the vicinity of Esperance were such that the pilot's decision to attempt the flight indicated a low appreciation, or an acceptance, of the associated risks. The attempted approach and landing under those conditions represented a significant level of risk for any flight attempted under the night VFR.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-009
Occurrence date 26/05/2007
Location near Esperance Aerodrome
State Western Australia
Report release date 17/10/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Collision with terrain
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Piper Aircraft Corp
Model PA-28
Registration VH-FTT
Serial number 28R-7918047
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point Jandakot, WA
Destination Esperance, WA
Damage Destroyed

Engine failure, 259 km south-south-east of Broome, Western Australia, on 24 May 2007, VH-IWO, Raytheon Beechcraft B200 King Air

Summary

A Raytheon Beech King Air aircraft, registration VH-IWO, was cruising at FL290 on an aero-medical flight from Newman to Fitzroy Crossing, WA with the pilot, a flight nurse and a doctor on board. When approximately 140 NM (259 km) south-south-east of Broome, the right engine inter-turbine temperature indication (ITT) was observed by the pilot to rise without any engine control input. The ITT rise was accompanied by a slight fluctuation in a number of associated engine indications. The pilot reduced power on the right engine.

Shortly after the power reduction, there was a slight right engine surge, with an accompanying rise in ITT. The pilot observed smoke coming from the right engine exhaust. The pilot shut down and secured the right engine and, after briefing the flight nurse and doctor, diverted to Broome Airport where a single-engine landing was completed.

Examination of the right engine revealed extensive damage caused by the separation of one of the compressor turbine blades at mid span.

As a result of this occurrence, the engine manufacturer has modified the alerting feature in the case of the interruption of the supply of electronic trend monitoring (ECTM) information to customers from its automated ECTM program.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-008
Occurrence date 24/05/2007
Location Fitzroy Crossing Aero.
State Western Australia
Report release date 23/12/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Engine failure or malfunction
Occurrence class Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Raytheon Aircraft Company
Model 200
Registration VH-IWO
Serial number BB1639
Sector Turboprop
Operation type Medical Transport
Departure point Newman, WA
Destination Fitzroy Crossing, WA
Damage Nil

Engine failure and ditching, near Warraber Island, Torres Strait, 23 May 2007, VH-PYD, Piper PA-32-260

Summary

At about 1030 Eastern Standard Time on 23 May 2007, a Piper Aircraft Inc. PA-32-260 aircraft, registered VH-PYD (PYD), departed Horn Island, Queensland, for a visual flight rules charter flight to Warraber Island, Queensland, with the pilot and three passengers onboard. Approximately 25 NM from Warraber Island, the aircraft experienced difficulties with the powerplant and was forced to ditch into the waters of the Torres Strait. Having received only minor injuries, the occupants exited the aircraft before it sank. The occupants were located and rescued within an hour of the ditching.

Shortly after commencing the descent into Warraber Island, the pilot noticed that the engine speed had increased beyond the normal range. Several unsuccessful attempts were made to reduce the engine speed, and within a short time the engine stopped producing power. Without engine power, the aircraft was not able to maintain altitude and given the aircraft's distance from land was forced to ditch into the water.

Because the aircraft was not recovered, the factors that resulted in the powerplant failure could not be determined; however, it was probable that they were related to a problem with the forward most crankshaft bearing.

In addition to the favourable sea, the pilot's recently acquired knowledge from the company's emergency procedures training likely contributed to the successful ditching.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-007
Occurrence date 23/05/2007
Location 15NM SW Warraber Island
State Queensland
Report release date 27/10/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Engine failure or malfunction
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Minor

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Piper Aircraft Corp
Model PA-32
Registration VH-PYD
Serial number 32-17
Sector Piston
Operation type Charter
Departure point Horn Island, Qld
Destination Warraber Is, Qld
Damage Destroyed

Airprox event between de Havilland Canada,VH-TQP, Beech Aircraft, VH-ILS, Aeroprakt Ltd, 24-4422, Port Macquarie Aerodrome, New South Wales, on 17 May 2007

Summary

On 17 May 2007, a de Havilland Dash 8, registered VH-TQP, and a Beechcraft Baron D55, registered VH-ILS, were operating in the vicinity of the Port Macquarie CTAF(R) Aerodrome. At the same time, the pilot of an Aeroprakt A22 Foxbat, registered 24-4422, was taxiing to conduct circuits from runway 21. The Foxbat was operating under the visual flight rules (VFR).

The pilot of the Baron initiated a go-round from short final approach to runway 03 as the Foxbat took off from runway 21. The crew of the Dash-8 subsequently conducted a go-round from final as the pilot of the Foxbat also turned onto final for runway 21 in front of the Dash-8.

A short time later, the pilot of the Foxbat landed without further incident. A club instructor inspected the Foxbat's radio after engine shutdown and found that the radio volume was at a low setting.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-006
Occurrence date 17/05/2007
Location Port Macquarie
State New South Wales
Report release date 28/08/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Near collision
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer De Havilland Canada/De Havilland Aircraft of Canada
Model DHC-8
Registration VH-TQP
Serial number 135
Sector Turboprop
Operation type Air Transport Low Capacity
Departure point Sydney, NSW
Destination Port Macquarie, NSW
Damage Nil

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Beech Aircraft Corp
Model 55
Registration VH-ILS
Serial number TE-751
Sector Piston
Operation type Flying Training
Destination Port Macquarie, NSW
Damage Nil

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Aeroprakt Ltd
Model A22
Registration 24-4422
Serial number 2005/121
Sector Piston
Operation type Sports Aviation
Departure point Port Macquarie, NSW
Destination Port Macquarie, NSW
Damage Nil

Breakdown of Separation - Boeing 767-300, Saab 340B, 19 km west-south-west of Sydney Airport, New South Wales, on 8 May 2007

Summary

On 8 May 2007 at about 1858 Eastern Standard Time, a Boeing Aircraft Company 767-338 (767), registered VH-OGI, was inbound to Sydney, NSW from Melbourne, Vic. on descent to 6,000 ft and a SAAB Aircraft Company 340B (SAAB), registered VH-OLL, was departing Sydney for Moruya, NSW on climb to FL140. The distance between the aircraft reduced to 1.5 NM horizontal and 400 ft vertical separation. Separation standards as specified in the Manual of Air Traffic Services (MATS) required the provision of either 3 NM horizontal or 1,000 ft vertical separation between the aircraft. There was a breakdown of separation.

The apparent distraction of the controller by his involvement in a non-operational control room discussion would probably have adversely affected his mental 'air picture' and traffic planning. That included unintentionally clearing the flight crew of the SAAB to climb through the assigned level of the inbound 767, rather than the routinely assigned intermediate altitude of 5,000 ft. The traffic manager's preoccupation with administrative duties meant that the monitoring and control of the distraction risk and operational activities in the control room was ineffective.

Action by the controllers to issue traffic information to the flight crew of the 767 and a radar vector and altitude limit to the flight crew of the SAAB quickly re-established the required separation standards.

Although no safety issue was identified as a result of this investigation, in its submission in response to the draft report, Airservices Australia (Airservices) advised of its development of an Air Traffic Control (ATC) Reform initiative. The aim of that initiative was to improve the structure and processes used by Airservices to verify ATC operational performance. At the time of writing this report, the initiative was in the design phase, with implementation planned for early 2009.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-003
Occurrence date 08/05/2007
Location 19 km WSW of Sydney Airport
State New South Wales
Report release date 12/02/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Loss of separation
Occurrence class Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer The Boeing Company
Model 767
Registration VH-OGI
Serial number 25246
Sector Jet
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Melbourne, Vic.
Destination Sydney, NSW
Damage Nil

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Saab Aircraft Co.
Model 340
Registration VH-OLL
Serial number 340B-175
Sector Turboprop
Operation type Air Transport Low Capacity
Departure point Sydney, NSW
Destination Moruya, NSW
Damage Nil

Procedures related event, Townsville Airport, Queensland, on 4 May 2007, N7088S, Raytheon Aircraft Company 390

Summary

On the night of 3 May 2007, a Raytheon Aircraft Company 390, registered N7088S, was enroute to Townsville Airport, Qld on the final leg of a private instrument flight rules (IFR) flight from Avalon, Vic via Sydney, NSW and Brisbane, Qld. The aircraft carried four passengers and a pilot. At about 0049 EST on 4 May, the pilot landed the aircraft on runway 01 while it was closed due to works in progress. There was no damage to the aircraft or injuries to personnel.

On 29 April 2007, a notice to airmen (NOTAM) had been issued which required that pilots requiring the use of runway 01 provide 30 minutes prior notice to the works safety officer (WSO) on duty at the airport. The pilot of N7088S later reported that although he had reviewed the list of NOTAMs for the airport prior to the flight, he did not recall noting the runway closure and did not notify the WSO of his planned arrival. The WSO had been notified of the planned arrival of another aircraft and had selected the runway lighting ON in anticipation of its arrival. At the time of the occurrence, the instrument landing system approach aid for runway 01 was available and the airport's pilot activated lighting and airfield frequency response unit were unavailable.

For a period of several minutes while on approach and final, the pilot was not contactable by radio on either the Brisbane Centre frequency or the Townsville common traffic advisory frequency. During this time the duty supervisor at Brisbane Centre notified the WSO of the approaching aircraft. Workers on the runway noticed the approaching aircraft and vacated the runway before the aircraft landed.

The investigation identified several safety factors that contributed to the occurrence, including pre-flight planning, radio selection and operation, ground works management, and air traffic control. The airport operator, the pilot, and Airservices Australia initiated a number of safety actions in response to some of the issues identified.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-005
Occurrence date 04/05/2007
Location Townsville Airport
State Queensland
Report release date 17/06/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Depart/app/land wrong runway
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Raytheon Aircraft Company
Model 390
Registration N7088S
Serial number RB-188
Sector Jet
Operation type Private
Departure point Brisbane, Qld
Destination Townsville, Qld
Damage Nil

Airprox - Princess Charlotte Bay, Queensland, Dornier DO 228-202K, VH-YJD, Cessna T210M, VH-FGW, on 25 April 2007

Summary

On 25 April 2007, at approximately 1155 Eastern Standard Time (EST), the pilots of a Dornier Werke GMBH DO 228-202 K (Dornier), registered VH-YJD, sighted an aircraft at the same altitude approaching from the opposite direction while flying over Princess Charlotte Bay, Qld. The pilot flying the Dornier immediately climbed and turned the aircraft to the left to avoid the approaching aircraft. The conflicting aircraft passed 50 to 100 ft below the right wing of the Dornier. A Cessna Aircraft Company T210M (Cessna), registered VH-FGW, was subsequently identified as the other aircraft. There had been an Airprox.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-004
Occurrence date 25/04/2007
Location 83km NW of KIMMI (IFR)
State Queensland
Report release date 29/10/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Near collision
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Dornier Werke GmbH
Model DO228
Registration VH-YJD
Serial number 8174
Sector Turboprop
Operation type Charter
Departure point Horn Island, Qld
Destination Cairns, Qld
Damage Nil

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 210
Registration VH-FGW
Serial number 21061619
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point Cairns, Qld
Destination Horn Island, Qld
Damage Nil

Breakdown of separation, 157 km east of Darwin, Northern Territory, on 19 April 2007, VH-AZJ, Piper PA-31 and VH-TFF, Cessna 210N

Summary

On 19 April 2007, the Darwin radar (DNR) airspace was being operated as a non-radar procedural sector due to the removal of the Australian Defence Air Traffic System (ADATS) radar data from the civil Australian Advanced Air Traffic System (TAAATS). That change in arrangements was necessary because of ongoing technical problems with the integration of the ADF data into the civil radar system.

At about 0909 Central Standard Time, the DNR controller identified that an instrument flight rules (IFR) Cessna Aircraft Company C210N, tracking from Darwin to Gove, NT at an altitude of 9,000 ft, was in conflict with an IFR Piper Aircraft Corporation PA31-350 that was tracking from Bathurst Island to Jabiru and that a breakdown of separation standards had occurred. The controller re-established the required separation.

The investigation identified that the safety management system employed by Airservices Australia did not require the conduct of an independent review of the locally conducted hazard assessment process that was utilised to manage the controller's loss of radar surveillance capabilities. This was considered to be a safety issue.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-002
Occurrence date 19/04/2007
Location 157km East of Darwin Aero.
State Northern Territory
Report release date 25/06/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Loss of separation
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Piper Aircraft Corp
Model PA-31
Registration VH-AZJ
Serial number 31-8152152
Sector Piston
Operation type Air Transport Low Capacity
Departure point Bathurst Island, NT
Destination Jabiru, NT
Damage Nil

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 210
Registration VH-TFF
Serial number 21064277
Sector Piston
Operation type Air Transport Low Capacity
Departure point Darwin, NT
Destination Gove, NT
Damage Nil

Microburst event - Sydney Airport, New South Wales, on 15 April 2007, VH-OJR, Boeing 747-438

Preliminary report

Preliminary report released 24 July 2007

On 15 April 2007, a Boeing Company 747-438 aircraft, registered VH-OJR, was being operating on a scheduled passenger flight from Singapore to Sydney, NSW. At 1923 Eastern Standard Time, the aircraft was positioned on a short final approach for a landing on runway 16R when it encountered rapidly changing wind conditions. The aircraft touched down firmly and the crew conducted a go around.

The investigation is continuing.

Summary

On 15 April 2007, a Boeing Company 747-438 aircraft, registered VH-OJR, was being operated on a scheduled passenger flight from Singapore to Sydney, NSW. On board the aircraft were 19 crew and 355 passengers. At 1923 Eastern Standard Time, the aircraft was about 100 ft above ground level prior to landing on runway 16 Right (16R) when it encountered a significant and rapid change in wind conditions. The aircraft touched down heavily and the windshear warning sounded in the cockpit. The crew conducted the windshear escape manoeuvre and made a second approach and landing.

The airport was under the influence a line of high-based thunderstorms associated with light, intermittent rain. Investigation revealed that the aircraft was influenced by outflow descending from a high-based storm cell that developed into a microburst. The airport did not have a windshear warning system. Pilots of aircraft operating on the reciprocal runway had previously reported moderate windshear to air traffic control, and the surface wind conditions had changed rapidly. However, that information was not communicated to the occurrence aircraft by air traffic control.

In response to this occurrence, the Bureau of Meteorology commenced a Sydney Airport Wind Shear Study to assess options for providing the aviation industry with low altitude windshear alerts. That study is scheduled for completion in April 2010.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-001
Occurrence date 15/04/2007
Location Sydney Airport
State New South Wales
Report release date 21/12/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Hard landing
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer The Boeing Company
Model 747
Registration VH-OJR
Serial number 25547
Sector Jet
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Singapore
Destination Sydney, NSW
Damage Nil

In-flight engine failure, 9km north-east of Wagga Wagga, New South Wales, de Havilland Canada Dash 8, VH-TQY, on 11 April 2007

Summary

On 11 April 2007, shortly after take-off from Wagga Wagga Airport, NSW, the crew of a de Havilland Dash 8 aircraft registered VH-TQY, noticed an unusual popping sound, followed by a slight vibration through the power levers. On passing 3,800 ft there was a significant drop in torque on the left engine, with associated popping noise. The crew shut down the engine and returned to Wagga Wagga Airport. After initial inspection on the wing, the engine was removed and sent to the manufacturer for disassembly and examination.

The examination found that the engine's number 5 bearing, the high pressure (HP) turbine disc and stub-shaft had failed. These components were sent to the Australian Transport Safety Bureau for further examination. That examination determined the number 5 bearing had failed at its roller cage through fatigue cracking, the stub-shaft had failed under overload and the HP turbine disc had suffered blade tip rubbing.

The operator had experienced a previous number 5 bearing failure on another of its engines. That bearing displayed the same failure pattern of its roller cage and was consecutively serial numbered to the VH-TYQ engine's number 5 bearing.

As a result of this investigation, the engine manufacturer identified a batch of 15 bearings that required replacement and introduced procedures to minimise the risk of further number 5 bearing failures.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 200702219
Occurrence date 11/04/2007
Location 5NM northeast of Wagga Wagga
State New South Wales
Report release date 12/06/2008
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Engine failure or malfunction
Occurrence class Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer De Havilland Canada/De Havilland Aircraft of Canada
Model DHC-8
Registration VH-TQY
Serial number 552
Sector Turboprop
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Wagga Wagga, NSW
Destination Sydney, NSW
Damage Nil