McDonnell Douglas DC9-31, VH-TJU, Brisbane QLD, 26 September 1986

Summary

The aircraft was being taxied to a parking bay at the completion of the flight. The pilot observed a fuel tanker parked near the edge of his taxi- path and moved the aircraft so that the nosewheel was tracking 4.6 metres to the right of the marked lead-in line. Just after this the marshaller assumed the responsibility for directing the aircraft to the parking bay. He directed the pilot to taxi straight ahead but the left wingtip struck the rear of the fuel tanker. The aircraft was stopped and the passengers and crew evacuated. The tank of the fuel tanker was damaged but not holed, and about two metres of the outboard section of the left wing of the aircraft was bent. The fuel tanker had been positioned to refuel an Australian Airlines Jetstream aircraft. The rear of the tanker encroached slightly on the taxiway. It was revealed during the investigation that groundstaff responsible for the positioning of the tanker were unaware of the correct meaning of the various taxiway markings. They had believed that the markings at the edge of the taxiway indicated the limit of the area on which servicing vehicles could be parked. The markings, in fact, indicated the limits of the full strength and low strength pavement. Both the marshaller and the pilot misjudged the clearance between the wingtip of the aircraft and the tanker.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198602666
Occurrence date 26/09/1986
Location Brisbane
Report release date 29/05/1987
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer McDonnell Douglas Corp.
Model DC-9
Registration VH-TJU
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Rockhampton QLD
Destination Brisbane QLD
Damage Substantial

Glasflugel Libelle 210 B, VH-GGS, Murrami (28 km NW Leeton) NSW, 19 January 1986

Summary

The pilot was competing in the Australian National Gliding championships. An outlanding became necessary when thermal activity declined and an approach was made to a dry field which was used for irrigation. On the downwind leg of the circuit, the pilot noted that a ditch crossed the field, however this ditch was not visible to him when on final approach. During the landing roll the glider collided with the ditch. The pilot had overflown a more suitable landing area, with the intention of making the outlanding closer to the destination aerodrome. The paddock ultimately selected was the most suitable in the vicinity, but required an approach between clumps of trees and alongside a power line. During the latter stages of the approach the pilot's vision was affected by sun glare.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198602304
Occurrence date 19/01/1986
Location Murrami (28 km NW Leeton)
Report release date 05/08/1986
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Glasflugel
Model 201
Registration VH-GGS
Operation type Gliding
Departure point Leeton NSW
Destination Leeton NSW
Damage Substantial

Socata TB10, VH-JTJ, Luddenham NSW, 25 February 1987

Summary

The student was receiving training in forced landing procedures. The first three exercises were completed without incident. At the end of the fourth approach to the selected paddock, the student applied full power and initiated a climb, intending to return to 3000 feet for a further exercise. However, when the aircraft had reached about 1700 feet, the engine lost power. The instructor took control, but was unable to gain any response from the engine. The aircraft was landed in a paddock, and collided with a fence some 200 metres from the point of touchdown. Examination of the aircraft revealed that one fuel tank was empty, while the other tank contained about 7 litres of usable fuel. The engine had lost power when the fuel in one tank was exhausted, and air evidently entered the system, preventing normal engine response when the instructor selected the opposite tank. No dipstick had been available and the instructor, who did not rely on the aircraft fuel gauges, had made an erroneous visual assessment of the fuel quantity prior to DEPARTURE. The aircraft had flown for more than 5 hours since the last refuelling.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198702388
Occurrence date 25/02/1987
Location Luddenham
Report release date 30/04/1987
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer SOCATA-Groupe Aerospatiale
Model TB
Registration VH-JTJ
Operation type Flying Training
Departure point Bankstown NSW
Destination Bankstown NSW
Damage Substantial

Aerospatiale Puma SA330J, VH-WOA, 20km NW Karratha WA, 29 December 1986

Summary

During the return flight from the gas production platform, passing 2300 feet on descent into Karratha, the crew and passengers heard a muffled noise from the rear of the helicopter. The aircraft continued the descent in controlled flight for a short period of time before it yawed violently to the left and rolled to approximately 90 degrees of left bank. The co-pilot was flying the aircraft at the time and he lowered the collective lever and placed the aircraft into an autorotational descent. However, the aircraft continued to yaw to the left so the pilot took the controls and with the assistance of the co-pilot a controlled autorotational descent was resumed. The descent continued, during which time the co-pilot carried out a number of actions associated with the loss of some of the aircraft systems and armed the flotation bags. Shortly thereafter, the aircraft again rolled violently to the left to a bank angle of approximately 130 degrees. The pilot was able to regain some control and rolled the helicopter to an upright position, however the descent rate had increased. As a result of the violent yaws, the pilots' headsets were flung from their heads making communications between them extremely difficult. During the final stage of the descent the co-pilot was able to retrieve his headset and broadcast a MAYDAY call which was received by Karratha Control Tower. Just prior to impact with the sea, the pilot pulled on full collective to reduce the descent rate and cushion the landing. The helicopter impacted the surface with a low forward speed and yaw, slightly nose low and banked to the right. The time interval between the first indication of a problem and impact was 45 seconds. Following impact, the aircraft capsized and floated nose low with both the cockpit and cabin doors submerged. The crew and surviving passengers exited the fuselage via windows and doors in the cockpit and cabin areas. However, escape was hampered by the immediate influx of the cloudy seawater and bubbles created in the water. Obstructions in the form of dislodged internal panelling and headset attachment cords also had to be negotiated, and disorientation due to the aircraft's inverted attitude and its angle of rest, had to be resolved before escape was possible. The co-pilot made two attempts to rescue the two unaccounted for passengers, but the aircraft sank in 13 metres of water before he was able to do so. The recovery team advised that it appeared that the two victims had attempted to escape but failed to reach safety. The 15 survivors were rescued by a small fishing boat that was operating in the area of impact. The bodies of the deceased and the wreckage were recovered later on the day of the accident. Prior to impact with the sea the aircraft had suffered an inflight break up. The break up began when one tail rotor blade failed approximately one third of the way out from the blade attachment point. The loss of this section of the blade resulted in severe out of balance forces which caused extensive damage to the tail rotor, tail rotor gear box and mountings, horizontal stabilizer, vertical pylon, aft section of the tail boom and the tail rotor controls and systems. The blade leading edge spar and skin had suffered from fatigue cracking which significantly reduced the blade's load carrying capacity. The blade failed when the remaining unaffected metal in the leading edge spar and skin could no longer carry the inflight loads imposed on the blade. The fatigue cracking had originated from a small indentation in the rear face of the leading edge spar. The indentation was caused by a misaligned jig key used during the construction of the blade and the damage was not detected by the manufacturer's quality control inspection procedures. The subsequent fatigue cracking of the spar was not discovered by the operator although the inspection procedures used were in accordance with the manufacturer's recommendations. The losses of control during the descent were the result of inflight losses of essential aircraft structure and systems. There was no information available to the crew about the handling characteristics of the aircraft with significant sections of the rear stabilizers missing. The information on the aircraft handling characteristics, during autorotational descent with the flotation system inflated, was contradictory and inconclusive, therefore the pilot elected not to inflate the flotation bags during the descent. The co-pilot had intended inflating the bags just prior to impact, but because of cockpit workload insufficient time was available. The helicopter was not fitted with a system which would automatically activate the flotation bags upon entry into water.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198600155
Occurrence date 29/12/1986
Location 20km NW Karratha
Report release date 03/02/1988
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Aerospatiale Industries
Model SA330
Registration VH-WOA
Serial number 1526
Sector Helicopter
Operation type Charter
Departure point North Rankin 'A' Gas Production Platform
Destination Karratha
Damage Substantial

Glaser Dirks DG 300 Elan, ZK-GSS, 3.5 km North of Tungamah VIC, 18 January 1987

Summary

The pilot was on the final leg of a competition gliding exercise, when deteriorating lift made an outlanding necessary. Final approach to the selected paddock was into a 10 to 15 knot wind, but was also towards the setting sun. The pilot had difficulty in seeing ahead because of the sun glare, which was exaggerated by a thin film of dust on the canopy. The pilot failed to see powerlines ahead of the aircraft. Following collision with the wires, the aircraft struck the ground heavily. This accident was not the subject of an on scene investigation.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198701419
Occurrence date 18/01/1987
Location 3.5 km North of Tungamah
Report release date 13/04/1987
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Wirestrike
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Glaser-Dirks
Model DG-300
Registration ZK-GSS
Operation type Gliding
Departure point Benalla VIC
Destination Benalla VIC
Damage Substantial

Rolladen-Schneider LS 4A, VH-IID, "Iona" 30 Km SW Narromine NSW, 24 September 1989

Summary

The pilot was undertaking an outlanding after failing to complete an attempted 150 kilometre soaring flight. The selected landing area was large and flat and was sparsely covered by grass. After a normal touchdown the aircraft rolled for about 100 metres before the landing gear collapsed. The aircraft slid for a further 50 metres before coming to rest with substantial damage to the fuselage undersurfaces. The pilot reported the landing surface was very rough, probably due to the earlier movement of cattle during wet conditions. He was not sure that the roughness of the ground could be determined from the air. This accident was not the subject of a formal on scene investigation.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198902580
Occurrence date 24/09/1989
Location "Iona" 30 Km SW Narromine
Report release date 06/11/1989
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Rolladen-Schneider Flugzeugbau GmbH
Model LS4
Registration VH-IID
Serial number N/K
Operation type Gliding
Departure point Narromine NSW
Destination Narromine NSW
Damage Substantial

Cessna A185 F Floatplane, VH-SFS, 26 km NNW Cairns QLD (Aprx), 5 April 1984

Summary

The aircraft had been refuelled the previous afternoon and hangared overnight. When the pilot and passengers arrived the following morning, the pilot loaded their baggage and freight into the aircraft. The aircraft was pushed out of the hangar and the pilot carried out a pre-flight inspection. After the passengers boarded the aircraft the engine was started and an engine check completed before the aircraft was taxiied to commence take-off from runway 15. About 12 minutes after take-off, the pilot reported that the engine was malfunctioning. It subsequently lost power completely and the pilot was committed to a forced landing. The sea conditions were unfavourable for the aircraft type, with estimated strong winds and about a 1.5 metre swell. The aircraft cartwheeled on touchdown and sank almost immediately. The pilot and two of the passengers were able to free themselves from the sinking aircraft and make their way to the surface. There they supported themselves on the floats which had become detached from the aircraft during the landing. Their subsequent attempts to locate the aircraft and rescue the other passenger were unsuccessful. The three men were later rescued by a police boat. An extensive search of the area, at the time, failed to locate the missing aircraft. About twelve weeks after the accident the engine was located by a trawler and salvaged. Some seven weeks later the airframe was located by another trawler, it was also salvaged. Following the salvage of each part of the aircraft it was washed down and subjected to extensive examination. The immersion of the wreckage in salt water and the growth of marine life on the wreckage inhibited this examination. However, no fault was found that may have contributed to the accident. The investigation did reveal that at the time of take-off the aircraft was approximately 300 kilograms in excess of the maximum allowable all up weight.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198400019
Occurrence date 05/04/1984
Location 26 km NNW Cairns QLD (Aprx)
Report release date 28/10/1985
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 185
Registration VH-SFS
Operation type Business
Departure point Cairns QLD
Destination Stanley Island, 185 km NW Cooktown QLD
Damage Destroyed

Piper PA30 Twin Comanche, VH-TOD, 24 Km ENE Hay NSW, 3 May 1985

Summary

The pilot elected to conduct the flight at a very low height above the ground. The aircraft collided with power lines, which severed the top 10 centimetres of the rudder. Control of the aircraft was maintained and a safe landing was made at the intended destination.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 198502532
Occurrence date 03/05/1985
Location 24 Km ENE Hay
Report release date 29/07/1985
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Wirestrike
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Piper Aircraft Corp
Model PA-30
Registration VH-TOD
Operation type Charter
Departure point Hay NSW
Destination Griffith NSW
Damage Substantial

Eipper Quicksilver MXL11, 10-0341 (AUF), 10 km north-north-east of Jamieson, Victoria, on 14 April 1990

Summary

Circumstances:

At a height of about 30 feet after take-off the aircraft struck a power line, nosed over, and impacted the ground tail first. The pilot had not been aware of the power line which was difficult to see.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 199001177
Occurrence date 14/04/1990
Location 10 km north-north-east of Jamieson
State Victoria
Report release date 03/08/1990
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Wirestrike
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Quicksilver Enterprises Inc
Model MXL11
Registration 10-0341
Serial number N/K
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point 10km NNE of Jamieson VIC
Destination 10km NNE of Jamieson VIC
Damage Substantial

Austflight Drifter A-503, AUF-357, Lake Richardson (16 km east-north-east of Woomera), South Australia, on 22 September 1990

Summary

Circumstances:

The pilot landed the aircraft on a strip near the lake and visited a group of friends on the shore with his passenger. It was arranged that the pilot would return in the aircraft and fly past for some photographs to be taken. The first run past the group on the shore was made in an easterly direction. The aircraft was then seen to turn onto a westerly heading and position for a second flypast. The height of the aircraft above the water on the two passes was estimated to be about 60-80 feet although photographs of the event show it to be much lower. After passing over the observers on the last run, the aircraft was seen to turn towards the east and start a steep climb. Witnesses reported that the speed of the aircraft reduced rapidly, and, at about 150 feet above ground level, the engine noise apparently reduced or stopped. The aircraft then dropped the right wing and dived into the water. The aircraft was seen to sink rapidly and only the passenger extricated himself from the wreckage. He clung to the tail and was recovered quickly by rescuers in a power boat. Despite repeated dives, the pilot could not be reached, and his body was removed after the wreckage was towed to shore. Detailed investigation did not reveal any faults or anomalies in the aircraft which could have contributed to the accident. Damage to the propeller was consistent with a strike under power. It is considered that the reduced power at the top of the steep climb was pilot induced during the attempted execution of a stall turn type manoeuvre. Discussions with witnesses and club members revealed that the pilot was overconfident in his attitude to flying the ultralight and would not readily accept advice or counselling on his handling the aircraft. It was further revealed that the pilot was prepared to perform in front of an audience and the events on the day of the accident support the conclusion that the pilot was engaged in an impromptu display in front of friends at the lake shore.

Significant Factors:

The following factors were considered relevant to the development of the accident:

1. The pilot engaged in an impromptu flying display for friends.

2. The pilot attempted a manoeuvre at an altitude that provided insufficient height for recovery.

3. The pilot was probably complacent and overconfident in his ability to handle the aircraft.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 199000606
Occurrence date 22/09/1990
Location Lake Richardson (16 km east-north-east of Woomera)
State South Australia
Report release date 10/04/1991
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Loss of control
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Austflight U.L.A. Pty Ltd
Model 503
Registration 25-0357
Serial number DR89-0383
Sector Piston
Operation type Sports Aviation
Departure point Lake Richardson SA
Destination Woomera SA
Damage Substantial