Mid-air collision - 20 km south-east of Orange, New South Wales, Aerospatiale AS350-B2, VH-NFO and a Kawasaki BK117, VH-LXC, on 8 December 2009

AO-2009-075

Preliminary report

Preliminary report released 11 March 2010

On 8 December 2009 at about 1840 Eastern Daylight-saving Time, an Aerospatiale AS350-B2 helicopter, registered VH-NFO (NFO), and a Kawasaki BK117 helicopter, registered VH-LXC (LXC), were engaged in aerial firebombing operations about 20 km south-east of Orange Airport, New South Wales. The pilots were the only occupants of their respective helicopters. After the pilot of NFO had landed to refuel, he noticed damage to the trailing edge of the helicopter's vertical fin. In addition, the plastic navigation light cover on top of the vertical fin was broken. The pilot reported the damage to the pilot of LXC. Examination of LXC did not reveal any apparent damage. There were no injuries.

Summary

On 8 December 2009, at about 1840 Eastern Daylight-saving Time an Aerospatiale AS.350B helicopter, registered VH-NFO (NFO), and a Kawasaki BK117 helicopter, registered VH-LXC (LXC), were engaged in aerial firebombing operations about 20 km south-east of Orange Aerodrome, New South Wales (NSW). During one of the water drop sequences, while in the vicinity of the drop point, LXC‟s main rotor blade tip(s) contacted the trailing edge of NFO‟s vertical fin. There was light damage to NFO and there were no injuries, although the outcome could have been more serious.

There were no published procedures for pilots to follow to ensure separation from other aircraft when there was no air attack supervisor present. Instead, the system relied on the airmanship and experience of pilots to mutually arrange separation. In this case, the water source was about 600 m from the fire front and NFO had departed the water source shortly before LXC. The investigation established that neither pilot was aware of the position of the other helicopter as they approached the drop point.

In response to the occurrence, the NSW Rural Fire Service developed a series of mission management standard operating procedures, including the use of standard terminology for aerial firefighting activities. These were to be introduced to contracted and other operators via a series of workshops commencing in November 2010.

After being approached by a number of firefighting authorities, in July 2009 the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) commenced a Firefighting Review. In November 2009, a Firefighting Operations Manual project team was established including five CASA staff, one fire authority staff member, 11 industry representatives and one consultant to draft a proposed manual.  The aim was for the manual to standardise aerial firefighting procedures across the authorities. At the time of release of this report, the draft manual had been distributed to the various fire authorities for their review.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2009-075
Occurrence date 08/12/2009
Location 20 km SE of Orange
State New South Wales
Report release date 29/11/2010
Report status Final
Anticipated completion Q4 2010
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Airborne collision
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Aerospatiale Industries
Model AS350
Registration VH-NFO
Serial number 1823
Sector Helicopter
Operation type Aerial Work
Damage Minor

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Kawasaki Heavy Industries
Model BK117
Registration VH-LXC
Serial number 1019
Sector Helicopter
Operation type Aerial Work
Departure point Bathurst, NSW
Destination Macquarie Woods, NSW
Damage Nil