Mid-air collision - Cessna 172, VH-EUI and Avid Flyer, 28-0929, Latrobe Valley Aerodrome, Victoria, on 1 December 2007

Preliminary report

Preliminary report released 14 February 2008

On 1 December 2007 an Avid Flyer ultra-light aircraft and a Cessna 172 aircraft collided in midair within the circuit area of the Latrobe Valley aerodrome. The pilot in the Avid Flyer was fatally injured and the Cessna 172 was safely landed.


 

Summary

On 1 December 2007, a Cessna 172 aircraft and an Avid Flyer collided in midair while conducting circuit operations at Latrobe Valley Aerodrome, Victoria. The Cessna was being flown by a student pilot who was conducting a series of solo circuits and the Avid was being flown by an experienced pilot. The Cessna collided with the Avid from above and behind after both aircraft had turned onto the final leg of the circuit. The Avid descended uncontrolled and impacted the ground. The pilot was fatally injured. Although the Cessna sustained damage from the collision, the student pilot was able to land the aircraft.

The investigation revealed that the student pilot was unaware of the Avid's presence before turning onto final, even though both aircraft had been in the circuit for some time prior to the collision. Whereas there was no evidence that the common traffic advisory frequency procedures at the aerodrome were a factor in the occurrence, a radio broadcast that was made prior to the collision possibly contributed to the student becoming unaware of the position of the Avid.

The investigation also identified a safety issue in regard to the guidance contained in the flying school's operations manual. The flying school reported that, as a result of this accident, it has amended its operations manual to include guidance on competency-based training and risk management strategies for application to solo student flight operations. In addition, the flying school has implemented an electronic, competency-based training system and provided training on its use to the school instructors and students.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-065
Occurrence date 01/12/2007
Location Latrobe Valley Aerodrome
State Victoria
Report release date 25/11/2010
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Airborne collision
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 172
Registration VH-EUI
Serial number 17261133
Sector Piston
Operation type Flying Training
Departure point Latrobe Valley, Vic.
Destination Latrobe Valley, Vic.
Damage Minor

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Amateur Built Aircraft
Model Avid Flyer
Registration 28-0929
Serial number 699
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point Latrobe Valley, Vic.
Destination Latrobe Valley, Vic.
Damage Destroyed

Controlled flight into terrain - Lake Liddell, New South Wales, on 7 December 2007, Air Tractor AT-802, VH-LIS

Preliminary report

Preliminary report released 19 February 2008

On 7 December 2007, the pilot of an Air Tractor Inc. AT-802 aircraft, registered VH-LIS, was conducting a test flight at Lake Liddell, NSW. The purpose of that flight was to test an experimental in-flight water collection system using skis attached to the aircraft's main landing gear.

At about 0910 Eastern Daylight-saving time, the pilot was conducting the second test run of the day. After the aircraft had been in contact with the surface of the lake for about 36 seconds, witnesses observed the aircraft collide with the surface of the lake. The aircraft overturned and sank in about 9 metres of water. The pilot was fatally injured.

Examination of the aircraft wreckage showed impact damage consistent with the aircraft pitching nose down, about its right main landing gear while rotating to the right.

Summary

On 7 December 2007, the pilot of an Air Tractor Inc. AT-802 aircraft, registered VH-LIS, was conducting a test flight at Lake Liddell, NSW. The purpose of the flight was to test an experimental in-flight water collection system using skis attached to the aircraft's main landing gear.

At about 0910 Eastern Daylight-saving Time, the pilot was conducting the second test run of the day. After the aircraft skis had been in contact with the surface of the lake for 36 seconds, witnesses observed the aircraft pitching nose down, about its right main landing gear while rotating to the right. The aircraft then overturned and sank. The aircraft was substantially damaged and the pilot was fatally injured.

The investigation concluded that the right experimental ski breached the surface of the water which caused a substantial amount of drag to act on the right side of the aircraft, as a consequence, the aircraft became uncontrollable. The circumstances of this accident highlight the need for due diligence and detailed risk assessments to be performed as part of experimental test programs.

As a result of this incident, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) has proposed amendments to Advisory Circular 21-10 - Experimental Certificates to provide:

  • updated guidance information to persons applying for the issue of experimental certificates
  • advice on risk management for test pilots during experimental flight testing.

In addition, the Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) issued a safety recommendation to CASA in respect of the need to consider the safety of third parties, including on the ground or water, before issuing a Special Certificate of Airworthiness.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-066
Occurrence date 07/12/2007
Location Lake Liddell
State New South Wales
Report release date 25/06/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Air Tractor Inc
Model AT802
Registration VH-LIS
Serial number 802-0082
Sector Turboprop
Operation type Aerial Work
Departure point Scone, NSW
Destination Scone, NSW
Damage Substantial

Operational event Brisbane Airport, Queensland, on 25 November 2007

Summary

On 25 November 2007, a Gulfstream Aerospace Corporation G-IV aircraft, registered HB-IKR, was being operated on a charter flight from Brisbane Airport, Queensland to Sydney, New South Wales. At about 2225 Eastern Standard Time the pilot in command of the aircraft commenced a take-off run on taxiway Alpha, adjacent to the active runway 01. The aerodrome controller (ADC) instructed the pilot to cancel the take-off clearance. The crew stopped the take-off and the ADC instructed them to taxi to the end of the runway for a take-off using the full runway length. There were no injuries, or damage to the aircraft or airport infrastructure.

The investigation found that a combination of a cockpit equipment failure, inadequate pilot rest, deficient cockpit resource management practices and unfamiliarity with the airport layout were likely factors that lead to the occurrence.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-064
Occurrence date 25/11/2007
Location Brisbane Aerodrome
State Queensland
Report release date 21/04/2010
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Communications - Other
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Gulfstream Aerospace Corp
Model G-IV
Registration HB-IKR
Serial number 1159
Sector Jet
Operation type Charter
Departure point Brisbane, Qld
Destination Sydney, NSW
Damage Nil

Fumes event, 19 km east of Melbourne Airport, Victoria, on 23 November 2007, VH-OGG, Boeing 767-338

Summary

On 23 November 2007, a Boeing Company 767-338, registered VH-OGG, was being operated on a scheduled passenger service between Sydney, NSW and Melbourne, Vic. On board were two flight crew, seven cabin crew and 255 passengers. The aircraft departed Sydney at 1426 Eastern Daylight-saving Time (EDT).

At about 1455, a passenger reported to a flight attendant that he could smell fumes coming from the gasper air vent above his seat. The passenger later reported that the fumes smelled like jet exhaust. The passenger became unconscious and was administered oxygen. He regained consciousness within a few seconds of being administered oxygen. A second passenger, seated in the area, also reported feeling nauseous at the time.

The flight crew declared a state of urgency to air traffic control and began performing the 'Smoke or Fumes - Air Conditioning' checklist. The aircraft landed at Melbourne Airport at 1529.

There were no other reports of adverse effects from any of the other passengers or crew on board the flight. The two affected passengers had travelled extensively by air with no previous adverse reactions. The investigation could not determine whether the passengers' symptoms were as a result of fumes in the aircraft cabin, or whether there were other unidentified medical conditions that may have contributed to the symptoms exhibited by the two passengers.

The investigation identified a non-contributory safety issue related to adherence to curing times following application of corrosion inhibiting compounds in the aircraft's cargo bays. The report details safety action taken by the operator to address this safety issue.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-063
Occurrence date 23/11/2007
Location 19km East of Melbourne
State Victoria
Report release date 26/09/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Fumes
Occurrence class Incident
Highest injury level Minor

Aircraft details

Manufacturer The Boeing Company
Model 767
Registration VH-OGG
Serial number 24929
Sector Jet
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Sydney, NSW
Destination Melbourne, Vic
Damage Nil

Depressurisation event 246 km south-west of Coolangatta, Queensland, on 17 November 2007, VH-VBC, Boeing 737-7Q8

Summary

On 17 November 2007 a Boeing Company 737-7Q8 aircraft, registered VH-VBC, with two flight crew, four cabin crew and 145 passengers was being operated on a scheduled passenger service from Coolangatta, Queensland to Melbourne, Victoria. During the take-off, the Master Caution system activated and the right BLEED TRIP OFF light illuminated. The pilot in command, who was the pilot flying, elected to continue the take-off. Once airborne the Bleed Trip Off non-normal checklist was actioned. The right engine bleed could not be reset with the effect that, when above flight level (FL) 170 (17,000 ft above mean sea level), only the left engine bleed air was available for air-conditioning and cabin pressurisation.

At FL318 during the climb, the flight crew observed the left PACK TRIP OFF light illuminate, followed by a rapid loss in cabin pressure and the cabin rate of climb indicator showing a rate of climb of about 2,000 ft/min. The crew fitted their emergency oxygen masks, commenced the Emergency Descent checklist and began a rapid descent to 10,000 ft. During the descent, the cabin altitude exceeded 14,000 ft, at which time the passenger oxygen masks deployed automatically. The aircraft was diverted to Brisbane for landing. There were no reported injuries to passengers or crew and no damage to the aircraft.

The investigation found that a combination of technical faults contributed to the loss of pressurisation and identified a number of other safety factors relating to operational procedures and cabin crew knowledge of the passenger oxygen system.

The operator conducted an internal investigation of the incident and carried out a number of safety actions as a result. Those actions included the enhancement of a number of the operator's manuals and the amendment of the operator's cabin safety recurrent training. In addition, the operator's passenger oxygen use in-cabin brief was enhanced to include advice that oxygen would flow to passengers' masks even if the associated bag was not inflated.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-062
Occurrence date 17/11/2007
Location 246 km south-west of Coolangatta
State New South Wales
Report release date 29/04/2010
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Air/pressurisation
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer The Boeing Company
Model 737
Registration VH-VBC
Serial number 30638
Sector Jet
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Gold Coast, Qld.
Destination Melbourne, Vic.
Damage Nil

Collision with terrain, Uaroo Station, Pilbara, Western Australia, Cessna 172M, VH-TCS

Preliminary report

Preliminary report released 16 January 2008

Late in the afternoon on 15 November 2007, a Cessna Aircraft Company 172M aircraft, registered VH-TCS, took off from Uaroo Station, in the Pilbara region of WA, for a local flight under the visual flight rules. A witness driving in a northerly direction along the North West Coastal Highway reported seeing a column of 'dark smoke' in the direction of the property between about 1700 and 1730 Western Daylight-saving Time.

Witnesses discovered the aircraft wreckage on the side of a hill located about 500 m from the property landing strip on the morning of 17 November 2007. The aircraft had been destroyed by impact forces and a post-impact fire. The pilot, who was the sole occupant, was fatally injured.

Summary

At about 0730 Western Daylight-saving Time, on 17 November 2007, the wreckage of a Cessna Aircraft Company C172M aircraft, registered VH-TCS, was discovered on the side of a hill, at Uaroo Station, in the Pilbara region of WA, about 500 m from the property air strip. The aircraft had been destroyed by impact forces and a post-impact fire. The pilot, who was the sole occupant, had been fatally injured.

Information obtained from persons that knew the pilot indicated that he had most likely taken off from the airstrip during the morning of 16 November 2007, however, the actual time of the take-off could not be determined. There were no reported witnesses to the take-off, any subsequent flight, or the accident. Tyre marks made by the aircraft indicated that the aircraft had taken off from runway 27 to the west.

There was no evidence of an engine or aircraft system problem which could have contributed to the accident. There was no evidence that the pilot had a pre-existing physiological condition that could have contributed to the accident. The aircraft manufacturer's tabulated take-off data showed that the aircraft should have had sufficient performance to take-off from runway 27 and climb clear of terrain.

There is evidence to indicate the possibility of adverse meteorological phenomena such as strong wind gusts and willy-willies in the area on the days before, during and subsequent to the accident. The willy-willies were reported to be difficult to see, form and dissipate rapidly, and travel in the same direction as the prevailing wind.

While the reason that the aircraft impacted terrain could not be conclusively determined, it is probable that the aircraft encountered adverse meteorological phenomena such as strong wind gusts and willy-willies, after take-off from runway 27.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-060
Occurrence date 15/11/2007
Location Uaroo Station
State Western Australia
Report release date 16/01/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Collision with terrain
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 172
Registration VH-TCS
Serial number 17264194
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point Uaroo Station, WA
Destination Uaroo Station, WA
Damage Destroyed

Collision with water, approx. 24 km south-east of Inverloch, Victoria, on 17 November 2007, Cessna C337G, VH-CHU

Preliminary report

Preliminary report released 27 April 2008

This preliminary report details factual information established in the investigation’s early evidence collection phase and has been prepared to provide timely information to the industry and public. Preliminary reports contain no analysis or findings, which will be detailed in the investigation’s final report. The information contained in this preliminary report is released in accordance with section 25 of the Transport Safety Investigation Act 2003.

On 17 November 2007, the owner-pilot of a Cessna Aircraft Company C337G (Skymaster), registered VH-CHU, was conducting a private flight in accordance with the visual flight rules from Moorabbin Airport, Vic. to Merimbula, NSW. The pilot, who was accompanied by three passengers, had indicated that he would be tracking along the coast. The aircraft did not arrive at Merimbula and on 19 November 2007 aircraft wreckage and three of the deceased occupants were found on a beach between Venus Bay and Cape Liptrap, Vic. Some wreckage was later found in the sea, off the beach. There were no survivors.

Final report

On 17 November 2007, the owner-pilot of a Cessna Aircraft Company C337G (Skymaster), registered VH-CHU, was conducting a private flight in accordance with the visual flight rules (VFR) from Moorabbin Airport, Vic. to Merimbula, NSW. The pilot, who was accompanied by three passengers, had indicated that he would be tracking along the coast. The aircraft did not arrive at Merimbula and on 19 November 2007 aircraft wreckage and three of the deceased occupants were found on a beach between Venus Bay and Cape Liptrap, Vic. Wreckage was found on the beach and in the sea off the beach. There were no survivors.

The investigation found that while manoeuvring over water at low level in conditions of reduced visibility, the pilot probably became spatially disorientated and inadvertently descended into the water. A contributing factor was the pilot's lack of instrument flying qualification and minimal instrument flying training and experience.

While not a contributing safety factor, the aircraft was probably operated outside its specified weight and balance limits in the early stages of the flight, which had the potential to adversely affect the aircraft's performance and controllability. The operation of visual flight rules flights into instrument meteorological conditions (VFR into IMC) continues to be a significant risk factor in general aviation, but there are a number of countermeasures which can be used to reduce the risk.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-061
Occurrence date 17/11/2007
Location 24 km SE Inverloch
State Victoria
Report release date 05/01/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Collision with terrain
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 337
Registration VH-CHU
Serial number 33701773
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point Moorabbin, Vic
Destination Merimbula, NSW
Damage Destroyed

Hard landing - Boeing B737-3YO, PK-AWP, Polonia Aerodrome, Medan, Indonesia, 25 May 2007. Assistance to Indonesian National Transportation Safety Committee (NTSC).

Summary

On 25 May 2007, an Indonesian registered Boeing 737-3YO, PK-AWP, touched down heavily while landing at Polonia Airport, Medan, Indonesia. The landing resulted in nosewheel vibration, a deflated left nosewheel tyre and overheated brakes.

The flight data recorder (FDR) was recovered from the aircraft. The Indonesian National Transportation Safety Committee (NTSC) was responsible for investigating this incident. The NTSC requested ATSB assistance in the recovery of data from the FDR tape on 12 December 2007. The Executive Director of the ATSB approved the request. To protect the information supplied by the ATSB to the NTSC and investigation work undertaken to assist this agency, the ATSB initiated an investigation under the Transport Safety Investigation Act 2003.

The FDR tape was provided to the ATSB on 17 December 2007. The tape was found to be damaged and the recovery of data was problematic, however, the ATSB successfully recovered the incident flight data from the damaged FDR tape. A data listing and graphical representation of data recorded during the incident flight and a report describing the recovery procedures, were finalised on the 10 January 2008. This information was provided to the NTSC.

 

______________

Released in accordance with section 25 of the Transport Safety Investigation Act 2003.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AE-2007-068
Occurrence date 25/05/2007
Location Polonia Airport, Medan
State International
Report release date 04/03/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type External Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Model B737-3YO
Registration PK-AWP
Serial number 24905
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Soekarno-Hatta Int. Airport, Jakarta
Destination Polonia Airport, Medan, Indonesia
Damage Minor

Wirestrike - 20 km north of Elliott, Northern Territory, on 10 November 2007, VH-WLQ, Cessna 172N

Summary

On 10 November 2007 at approximately 0830 Central Standard Time, a Cessna Aircraft Company 172N, registered VH-WLQ, with two pilots and a passenger on board departed Katherine, NT on a private, visual flight rules (VFR) flight to Tennant Creek. At about 1030, the aircraft struck a powerline which spanned the Stuart Highway 20 km north of Elliott. The aircraft's tail section was broken rearwards from the aft fuselage, rendering the aircraft uncontrollable and causing it to impact the highway in a steep nose-down attitude. The three occupants were fatally injured. The aircraft was destroyed.

There was no evidence of an aircraft or operational reason for the flight below 500 ft above ground level (AGL). Based on a lack of evidence to the contrary, the investigation concluded that the descent to, and flight at low level was probably as a result of a conscious decision by the pilots.

The investigation was unable to establish which of the pilots was flying the aircraft at the time of the accident.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-058
Occurrence date 10/11/2007
Location 20 km north of Elliott
State Northern Territory
Report release date 30/10/2008
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category Wirestrike
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 172
Registration VH-WLQ
Serial number 17271888
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point Katherine, NT
Destination Tennant Creek, Northern Territory
Damage Destroyed

Procedures related event - Melbourne Airport, Victoria, on 4 November 2007, HS-TJW, Boeing 777-2D7

Preliminary

Preliminary report released 21 January 2008

On 4 November 2007, a Boeing Company 777-2D7 aircraft, registered HS-TJW, was being operated on a scheduled passenger service from Bangkok, Thailand, to Melbourne, Vic, with 17 crew and 277 passengers on board. During a non-directional beacon (NDB) non-precision approach to runway 16 at Melbourne Airport, the aircraft descended below the segment minimum safe altitude at 6.8 distance measuring equipment (DME, a measure in nautical miles). Soon after, the crew received two enhanced ground proximity warning system (EGPWS) cautions. The crew then levelled the aircraft and conducted a visual approach and landing on runway 16.

Summary

On 4 November 2007, a Boeing Company 777-2D7 (777) aircraft, registered HS-TJW, was being operated on a scheduled passenger service from Bangkok, Thailand to Melbourne, Vic. with 17 crew and 277 passengers on board. During the conduct of a non-directional beacon (NDB) non-precision approach to runway 16 at Melbourne, the crew descended the aircraft below a segment minimum safe altitude. Soon after, the crew received two enhanced ground proximity warning system cautions. At that time, the crew became visual with the ground below and the Melbourne aerodrome controller observed the aircraft 'unusually low for an aircraft'. The crew levelled the aircraft and made a visual approach and landed, on runway 16.

The investigation found that the aircraft had descended below a critical altitude whilst carrying out an NDB approach and that the crew did not monitor the aircraft's progress correctly during the NDB approach.

The aircraft operator had known about the difficulties in flying approaches without constant angle approach paths and was in the process of training flight crews on procedures specific to NDB approaches when the incident occurred. In October 2007, the operator introduced a training program to instruct pilots on a new method to conduct those approaches. At the time of the incident, the pilots of the 777 had not undergone that training.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number AO-2007-055
Occurrence date 04/11/2007
Location Melbourne Aerodrome
State Victoria
Report release date 29/06/2009
Report status Final
Investigation level Systemic
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category E/GPWS warning
Occurrence class Serious Incident
Highest injury level None

Aircraft details

Manufacturer The Boeing Company
Model 777
Registration HS-TJW
Serial number 34591
Sector Jet
Operation type Air Transport High Capacity
Departure point Bangkok, Thailand
Destination Melbourne, Victoria
Damage Nil