Aviation safety investigations & reports

Cessna Aircraft Company 207, VH-EHL

Investigation number:
200205223
Status: Completed
Investigation completed

Summary

The Cessna 207 aircraft (C207) was engaged on a sight-seeing flight from Cradle Mountain, to Lake St. Clair and return. On board were the pilot and 4 passengers. The flight departed Cradle Mountain at approximately 1310 ESuT and tracked direct to Lake St Clair at 7000 ft due to turbulence. The aircraft then returned to Cradle Mountain.

At approximately 1404, as the aircraft was approaching the airfield, the pilot configured the aircraft for a straight in approach to strip 02. The pilot had selected two stages of flap, and had reduced power to approximately 19 inches of manifold pressure. He reported that at approximately half a mile from the airfield the engine stopped without any prior warning. After completing trouble checks, the pilot became aware that the aircraft would not reach the airfield. He then manoeuvred the aircraft towards an open area on his right while broadcasting a MAYDAY call. Melbourne air traffic control acknowledged this call. The pilot then completed additional trouble checks and changed the fuel tank selection, but the engine failed to respond.

The aircraft touched down heavily on the main wheels and slid approximately 40 metres before coming to a stop. During the touchdown and subsequent ground slide, the nose wheel detached from the aircraft, the propeller was damaged and the right wing was partially separated from the airframe. After the aircraft stopped the pilot checked the passengers and discovered that two of them had suffered serious injuries. As fuel was leaking from the damaged right wing, the pilot and uninjured passenger assisted the injured passengers from the aircraft. The pilot was then able to make his way to the airstrip to raise the alarm. The Australian Transport Safety Bureau did not attend the site but conducted the investigation relying upon information provided by the pilot, the operator, and the Bureau of Meteorology.

The pilot reported that he had completed a daily inspection of the aircraft earlier in the morning. That inspection included assessing the fuel quantity on board the aircraft and completing a fuel drain and water check. Both of these checks did not reveal any problem with the fuel. The pilot estimated that there was approximately 185 litres of fuel on board the aircraft, 90 litres in the right tank and 95 litres in the left tank. The aircraft had last been refuelled the day previously from drum stock. The aircraft had completed two flights since that refuelling with no problems being reported. The engineers that recovered the aircraft reported that there was approximately 30 litres of fuel in the left tank and approximately 100 litres of fuel in the right tank.

The C207 aircraft has a fuel selector in the cockpit that allows the pilot to supply fuel to the engine from either the right tank or the left tank, but not from both tanks simultaneously. The pilot reported that he conducted the flight with the fuel selector switched to the left tank. He also reported that he did not move the selector during the flight and only moved it to the right tank as part of his trouble checks when the engine failed.

The pilot reported that he did not complete flight or fuel plans for the flight, but operated on previous knowledge from other flights. A post occurrence analysis of the weather indicated that the winds at 7000 feet were as forecast. Post flight analysis of the flight revealed that the aircraft would have required 57 litres of fuel to complete the flight, which included allowances for taxi and climb.

The engine was sent by the owner to an engine overhaul facility for testing. The ATSB did not attend the testing of the engine. The engine was fitted to the test cell in the condition as removed from the aircraft. The engine was started and test run in accordance with the engine manufacturer's overhaul manual. The engine ran normally and all temperature and pressure limits were within normal ranges.

The investigation was unable to determine why the engine failed to operate normally in the latter stages of the flight.

General details
Date: 07 November 2002   Investigation status: Completed  
Time: 1404 hours ESuT    
Location   (show map): 4 km S Cradle Mountain (Valley)    
State: Tasmania   Occurrence type: Forced/precautionary landing  
Release date: 22 July 2003   Occurrence category: Accident  
Report status: Final   Highest injury level: Serious  

Aircraft details

Aircraft details
Aircraft manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company  
Aircraft model 207  
Aircraft registration VH-EHL  
Serial number 20700141  
Type of operation Charter  
Damage to aircraft Substantial  
Departure point Cradle Mountain (ALA), TAS  
Departure time 1310 hours ESuT  
Destination Cradle Mountain (ALA), TAS  
Crew details
Role Class of licence Hours on type Hours total
Pilot-in-Command Commercial 180.0 730
 
Injuries
  Crew Passenger Ground Total
Serious: 0 2 0 2
Total: 0 2 0 2
Last update 13 May 2014