Investigation number
199203448
Occurrence date
State
New South Wales
Report release date
Report status
Final
Investigation type
Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status
Completed
Aviation occurrence category
Loss of separation
Occurrence class
Incident

VH-NID [DHC8] had departed Sydney for Port Macquarie and was maintaining Flight Level [FL]170 and passed Williamtown at 2139 estimating Port Macquarie at 2202 hours[All times are UTC]. VH-RUI [PA31] taxied at Port Macquarie for Williamtown at 2149 hours and was passed traffic on VH-NID by Sydney Flight Service [FS]. At 2150 hours VH-NID called on area frequency and reported leaving FL150 on descent with a circuit estimate for Port Macquarie of 2159 hours. FS passed traffic on VH-RUI to VH-NID informing the crew that VH-RUI was taxiing and would climb to 6000ft. At 2151 hours VH-RUI gave his departure call on area frequency as time 50 and climbing to 6000ft. No further calls were made by either crew until 2157.30 hours when VH-NID advised on area frequency that he was changing to MTAF and asked Sydney to confirm the altitude of VH-RUI as 2000ft. VH-RUI advised that he was maintaining 6000ft. Interviews confirm that the incident occurred approximately one minute prior to this transmission. Both crews agree that the occurrence was approximately 15-20nm south of Port Macquarie and the Automatic Voice Recorder [AVR] analysis, when combined with pilot reports, put the time of passing at between 2156.30 and 2157.00 hours. The pilot of VH-RUI stated that he first saw VH-NID descending in front of him and about 300ft above, causing him to take violent evasive action. The crew of VH-NID stated that they saw VH-RUI about 1000m to their left when approaching 7000ft and therefore had no need to limit their descent. Both crews were given traffic information on each other in a correct and timely manner and stated that they were on track. The weather was fine with no cloud.

Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
De Havilland Canada/De Havilland Aircraft of Canada
Model
DHC-8-103
Registration
VH-NID
Sector
Turboprop
Departure point
Sydney
Destination
Port Macquarie
Damage
Nil
Aircraft Details
Manufacturer
Piper Aircraft Corp
Model
PA-31-350
Registration
VH-RUI
Sector
Piston
Departure point
Port Macquarie NSW
Destination
Williamtown NSW
Damage
Nil