VFR into IMC involving Cessna 172C, VH-JLG, 7 km south of Coffs Harbour, New South Wales

199300131

Summary

The aircraft had been cleared to track south over water at 1,000 feet through the Coffs Harbour zone. At 1324 hours the pilot reported passing Woolgoolga and subsequently reported abeam the control tower. At this time he requested clearance to descend to 500 feet. He was cleared to descend, but two minutes later, at 1334 hours the pilot reported that he was returning to Coffs Harbour for a landing and that he had lost visual contact with the water. He was cleared to join the circuit on downwind for runway 21 on a visual approach and was asked to report abeam the control tower. This was acknowledged by the pilot at 1334:51, but there was no further communication from the aircraft. An overflying jet aircraft reported receiving a transmission from a VHF Survival Beacon for a period of about 10 seconds shortly after the time of the pilot's last transmission.

The Automatic Terminal Information Service (ATIS) was reporting 3 octa of cloud at 1,000 feet, with lower patches, and 4 octa of cloud at 2,000 feet. Showers were reported in the area.

The aircraft wreckage was located in the sea near Sawtell. Wreckage examination suggests the aircraft struck the water in a descending right turn. There was no indication that the aircraft was not capable of normal flight immediately prior to the accident. A heavy rainstorm was reported near Sawtell at the time of the accident. The pilot was not qualified for flight in other than visual conditions. It is most probable that the aircraft inadvertently entered a heavy rain shower which deprived the pilot of visual contact with the land and water. The pilot attempted a turn to head back to Coffs Harbour aerodrome but as he was not qualified for flight by sole reference to the aircraft's flight instruments, it is probable the aircraft entered a steep descent from which the pilot was unable to effect a recovery prior to collision with the sea.

Significant Factors

1. The pilot inadvertently flew into conditions of limited visibility associated with a heavy rain shower.

2. The pilot was not qualified for flight by sole reference to the aircraft's flight instruments.

3. The conditions of visibility reduced such that the pilot was unable to continue the flight by visual reference to the land and water.

4. The pilot attempted to turn to regain visual contact and during the turn entered a descent from which he was unable to effect recovery prior to collision with the sea.

Occurrence summary

Investigation number 199300131
Occurrence date 18/02/1993
Location 7 km south of Coffs Harbour
Report release date 27/07/1993
Report status Final
Investigation type Occurrence Investigation
Investigation status Completed
Mode of transport Aviation
Aviation occurrence category VFR into IMC
Occurrence class Accident
Highest injury level Fatal

Aircraft details

Manufacturer Cessna Aircraft Company
Model 172
Registration VH-JLG
Serial number 17248836
Sector Piston
Operation type Private
Departure point Kooralbyn QLD
Destination Taree NSW
Damage Destroyed