On 15 April 2016, at about 1400 Western Standard Time, the student pilot of a Piper PA-28-181 aircraft, registered VH-BYE (BYE), departed from Jandakot Airport on a solo navigation training flight to Bunbury Airport, Western Australia. At about 1500, when about 10 NM north of Bunbury Airport, the pilot broadcast on the common traffic advisory frequency (CTAF) that they were inbound for a straight-in approach to runway 07.
At the time, a Cessna 152 aircraft, registered VH-CRP (CRP), was conducting circuit training at Bunbury Airport. On board CRP were an instructor and a student pilot. The active runway at Bunbury was 07, and the crew were broadcasting on the CTAF when on the downwind, base and final legs of the circuit.
After completing a touch-and-go landing, CRP was upwind of runway 07, at about 300 ft above ground level, when the student sighted BYE on a reciprocal track – on short final for runway 25, and alerted the instructor. The instructor took control of the aircraft and took avoiding action, turning right, and BYE passed about 50 to 100 ft below and to their left.
When on final approach, at about 400 ft above ground level, the pilot of BYE realised they were approaching runway 25 instead of 07 and saw CRP pass to their left. The pilot of BYE conducted a slight right turn and commenced a climb to 1,500 ft.
After the incident, both aircraft landed on runway 07.
This incident highlights the importance of thorough pre-flight planning and preparation. The Flight planning kit – always thinking ahead, available from CASA’s online store, can assist pilots in preparing for flight.
Aviation Short Investigations Bulletin - Issue 51
Read report
What happened
On 15 April 2016, at about 1400 Western Standard Time (WST), the student pilot of a Piper PA-28-181 aircraft, registered VH-BYE (BYE), departed from Jandakot Airport on a solo navigation training flight to Bunbury Airport, Western Australia. At about 1500, when about 10 NM north of Bunbury Airport, the pilot broadcast on the common traffic advisory frequency (CTAF) that they were inbound for a straight-in approach to runway 07.
At the time, a Cessna 152 aircraft, registered VH-CRP (CRP), was conducting circuit training at Bunbury Airport. On board CRP were an instructor and a student pilot. The active runway at Bunbury was 07, and the crew were broadcasting on the CTAF when on the downwind, base and final legs of the circuit.
The instructor of CRP heard the pilot of BYE broadcast inbound at 10 NM to the north. About 5 minutes later, the instructor heard the pilot of BYE broadcast they were joining a long final approach for a straight-in approach to runway 07. CRP was then on final approach for runway 07 and expected BYE to be behind them, but the pilots did not see BYE. The pilot of BYE heard the student pilot of CRP broadcast they were on final approach for runway 07, but also did not see the aircraft at that time.
After completing a touch-and-go landing, CRP was upwind of runway 07, at about 300 ft above ground level, when the student sighted an aircraft ahead and alerted the instructor. The instructor sighted BYE on a reciprocal track – on short final for runway 25, and took control of the aircraft from the student. The instructor of CRP took avoiding action, turning right, and BYE passed about 50 to 100 ft below and to their left.
When on final approach, at about 400 ft above ground level, the pilot of BYE sighted the numbers marked on the runway threshold, and realised they were approaching runway 25 instead of 07. At the same time, the pilot saw CRP pass to their left. The pilot of BYE conducted a slight right turn and commenced a climb to 1,500 ft.
After the incident, both aircraft landed on runway 07.
Pilot comments – pilot of VH-BYE
This was the pilot’s first solo navigation exercise. The pilot had done one touch-and-go at Bunbury about 4 weeks prior to the incident. The pilot had a briefing with their instructor prior to departing Jandakot, and discussed options for joining the circuit at Bunbury. The pilot had initially intended to join on the downwind leg of the circuit for runway 07, and could not recall why they amended the plan to make a straight-in approach.
ATSB comment
Pilots are encouraged to carefully consider options for joining the circuit during operations at non-towered aerodromes. With respect to straight-in approaches, Airservices Australia Aeronautical Information Package En Route 1.1 – 49.6 Straight-in Approach stated that ‘Straight-in approaches, whilst not prohibited, are not a recommended standard procedure’.
Straight-in approaches often limit the opportunity for a pilot to sight other circuit traffic, and join the circuit in a manner that avoids inconveniencing other traffic. Importantly, straight-in approaches also limit the opportunity for a pilot to effectively assess the aerodrome conditions and the status of movement areas, and identify any unexpected hazards.
Safety message
Following receipt of a broadcast from another aircraft in the vicinity, pilots should carefully assess the significance of the information in the context of their own intentions. In the event that potentially conflicting traffic cannot be visually identified, pilots should communicate accordingly and adopt a conservative course of action.
This incident highlights the importance of thorough pre-flight planning and preparation. The Flight planning kit – always thinking ahead, available from CASA’s online store, can assist pilots in preparing for flight.
