Jump to Content

On 13 February 2008, a Piper Aircraft Corporation PA-18 Super Cub aircraft and a Robinson Helicopter Company R44 Raven helicopter were engaged in feral goat culling operations in the Kennedy Range National Park, WA.

The two aircraft collided in mid-air as the pilot of the helicopter executed a climbing left turn that brought the two aircraft into close proximity. The pilot and shooter occupants of the R44 were aware that the Super Cub was approaching them at the same height, and the helicopter pilot was aware of the position of the aeroplane during the helicopter's climbing turn, but it appeared probable that the pilot and spotter occupants of the Super Cub did not see the helicopter.

The helicopter's main rotor blades struck the Super Cub's right wing, severing the lift struts. The right wing detached in flight, and the Super Cub fell to the ground. The pilot and spotter were fatally injured. The helicopter was able to land safely.

The investigation determined that the occupants of the Super Cub were probably unaware of the proximity of the R44, and that the R44 pilot did not recognise the collision hazard until there was insufficient time to prevent contact with the Super Cub.

The investigation also identified that there were no formalised operating procedures detailing the conduct of culling operations involving multiple aircraft that may have assisted in the maintenance of aircraft separation.

In response to this accident, a number of safety actions were undertaken by the R44 and Super Cub operators. In addition, extensive safety action was carried out by the WA Government departments that were involved in the operation. That included in the areas of risk management, the review and amendment of guidelines and procedures affecting multiple aircraft operations, the adoption of Safety Management Systems, and the provision of training for departmental personnel.

 

Interim Factual report released 11 November 2008

On 13 February 2008, a Piper Aircraft Corporation Super Cub aeroplane and a Robinson Helicopter Company R44 Raven helicopter collided in midair during feral goat culling operations. The aeroplane impacted the ground at a steep angle, fatally injuring the two occupants. The helicopter, though damaged, was safely landed.

 

Preliminary report released 20 March 2008

On 13 February 2008, a Piper Aircraft Corporation Super Cub aeroplane and a Robinson Helicopter Company R44 Raven helicopter collided in midair during feral goat culling operations. The aeroplane impacted the ground at a steep angle, fatally injuring the two occupants. The helicopter, though damaged, was safely landed.

 

Safety Actions for this investigation

 

General Details

Date: 13 Feb 2008Investigation Status: Completed
Time: 1914 WSuTInvestigation Type: Occurrence Investigation
Location: Kennedy Range National ParkOccurrence Type: Terrain Collision
State: WAOccurrence Class: Operational
Release Date: 26 Jun 2009Occurrence Category: Accident
Report Status: FinalHighest Injury Level: Fatal
 

Aircraft 1 Details

Aircraft Manufacturer: Robinson Helicopter Co
Aircraft Model: R-44
Aircraft Registration: VH-ZDP
Serial Number: 1246
Type of Operation: Aerial Work
Damage to Aircraft: Substantial
Departure Point:Gascoyne Junction (ALA)
Departure Time:1805 WSuT
Destination:Gascoyne Junction (ALA)

Aircraft 2 Details

Aircraft Manufacturer: Piper Aircraft Corp
Aircraft Model: PA-18-150
Aircraft Registration: VH-OUS
Serial Number: 18-7881
Type of Operation: Aerial Work
Damage to Aircraft: Destroyed
Departure Point:Gascoyne Junction (ALA)
Departure Time:1805 WSuT
Destination:Gascoyne Junction (ALA)
 

Injuries

 CrewPassengerGroundTotal
Fatal: 1102
Total:1102
Download Final Report
[PDF: 1.64MB]
 
 
Download Interim Factual
[PDF: 1.18MB]
 
 
Download Preliminary Report
[PDF: 728KB]
 
 
 
 
Last update 23 November 2010