Aviation safety investigations & reports

Ditching involving a Piper Aircraft Corp PA-28R-180, VH-BOP, 2km NW Wynyard, Aerodrome, TAS on 27 January 1997

Investigation number:
Status: Completed
Investigation completed


Download Final Report
[Download  PDF: 17KB]
During initial climb after takeoff from Wynyard the engine suffered a power loss. The pilot observed the manifold pressure decreasing so he selected alternate air, checked the mixture control was set to rich and checked the fuel pump was switched on. He changed the fuel selection from the left tank to the right tank, but the engine did not respond. By this time the aircraft was low over the water so the pilot transmitted a PAN call advising of the emergency and his intention to try to land on a beach. When the aircraft had descended to about three metres above the water and its speed had decayed to 60 knots, the pilot broadcast a MAYDAY call. Shortly afterwards the aircraft was stalled into the water at the mouth of the Inglis River. The impact forces broached the fuselage which rapidly filled with water. The pilot and his two passengers evacuated the aircraft before it sank and were rescued by the crew of a nearby fishing boat. The investigation into the cause of the engine power loss was hindered because the aircraft was badly damaged during the accident and the subsequent recovery exercise. It was established that sufficient fuel was on board for the proposed flight and fuel was available to the fuel distributor, but the contents of the fuel filter assembly could not be determined. The engine was inspected and disassembled and relevant components were tested. It was found that the air duct hose fitted between the air filter and the fuel control unit was collapsed due to disbonding of the internal supporting wire. It could not be determined if this had occurred prior to the ditching and was the cause of the power loss, or had occurred due to the forces/pressure of the water in the engine bay during the ditching. No other anomalies were found that could have caused the power loss. The air duct hose was one that is commonly called a 'SCAT' hose and was made up of a single layer of neoprene impregnated fabric material supported internally by a spring steel helix wire bonded to the fabric. This SCAT hose is not appproved by the manufacturer for this installation. The correct hose carries the manufacturer's part number and is constructed of a 2 ply silicone resin impregnated with woven fibreglass which is bonded and cured along with an inner liner and tabbed ends to facilitate retention. It is also wire reinforced with galvanised hard temper spring steel. The manufacturer of the SCAT hose has recently changed the specification for these hoses to say that they are 'not recommended for negative pressure applications'. Many aircraft have SCAT or similar hoses fitted to negative pressure engine intake systems, as was the case with this aircraft. Significant factors. 1. It is suspected that the SCAT hose collapsed reducing the inlet air supply to a level that precluded the engine from delivering full power. 2. The SCAT hose was not the hose that was designated by the manufacturer to be installed in the air inlet system. 3. The pilot was forced to ditch the aircraft into water. Safety action. 1. Information on engine intake hose installations is available in an article 'SCAT/SCEET hoses linked to engine failure' published in the CASA Flight Safety Australia Summer 1997 issue. 2. CASA advise that a program is being developed to examine the ramifications of the widespread use of SCAT hoses in engine negative pressure air inlet systems.
Download Final Report
[Download  PDF: 17KB]
General details
Date: 27 January 1997   Investigation status: Completed  
Time: 15:00 ESuT    
State: Tasmania   Occurrence type: Ditching  
Release date: 20 March 1997   Occurrence category: Accident  
Report status: Final   Highest injury level: Minor  

Aircraft details

Aircraft details
Aircraft manufacturer Piper Aircraft Corp  
Aircraft model PA-28R-180  
Aircraft registration VH-BOP  
Sector Piston  
Damage to aircraft Substantial  
Departure point Wynyard Tas  
Destination Moorabbin Vic