Jump to Content
Download Final Report
[ Download PDF: 25KB]

Both aircraft were conducting scenic flights over North Stradbroke and Moreton Islands. Neither the pilot of VH-WAS nor the pilots in VH-DMB submitted a flight plan (nor was it a requirement) and were operating NOSAR, NO DETAILS outside controlled airspace on a "see and be seen" basis. No routine radio transmissions were heard from either aircraft when they were in the South Passage Bar area. VH-DMB had flown over Moreton Island and was turning left at an angle of bank of 25 degrees when it collided with VH-WAS at 1500 feet above mean sea level over the South Passage Bar. The pilot of VH-WAS stated that his aircraft was turning through east, in a shallow right turn when he felt and heard an impact. It was immediately obvious to him that a wingtip section from the left wing was missing, but he was unaware of what his aircraft had struck. An uncontrolled, left, descending turn ensued and the aircraft descended about 1200 feet before the pilot managed to level the wings after reducing the engine power to idle. He transmitted a brief MAYDAY call during the recovery. The pilot successfully ditched the aircraft some 4 kilometres east of Reeders Point, Moreton Island. After the aircraft came to rest, it floated for about a minute before sinking in 7-8 metres of water. The pilot and his passenger escaped from the wreckage and each clung to a separated aircraft wheel. They then began to swim for the shore on the incoming tide. VH-DMB plummeted out of control and impacted in a near vertical dive on a shallow sand bank some 800 metres from the shore of North Stradbroke Island. Inspection of the wreckage found that the left wingtip of VH-WAS had struck the cockpit area of VH-DMB. It is probable that this impact disabled both the front seat occupants of VH-DMB. The left mainwheel of VH-WAS had severed a 1.2 metre section of the left wing of VH-DMB. The investigation determined that both aircraft were in a position to have been visible from the cockpit of the other aircraft for at least 10 seconds before impact. Several factors affect a pilots ability to observe other aircraft. In this case it is likely that the relative position of each aircraft to the other meant that they were in a constant position in the other pilots field of view. The pilot of VH-WAS was also looking in the direction of the sun and VH-DMB was coloured such that it would not have contrasted with the backdrop of a high overcast. Although the pilots in VH-DMB were looking down-sun it is possible that the small frontal cross-section presented by VH-WAS would have been lost against the background of the island and the horizon. Because of the nature of the sight-seeing flights being undertaken by both aircraft it is also possible that all pilots may have been partially distracted from their lookouts by passengers. As a result of a previous accident involving a mid-air collision, the Bureau of Air Safety Investigation has undertaken to conduct an evaluation and prepare a report on the practicality of the "see and be seen" principle.

Download Final Report
[ Download PDF: 25KB]
General details
Date: 07 August 1988 Investigation status: Completed 
Time: 924  
Location:South Passage Bar, Moreton Bay Investigation type: Occurrence Investigation 
State: Queensland Occurrence type: Airborne collision 
Release date: 29 June 1989 Occurrence class: Airspace 
Report status: Final Occurrence category: Accident 
 Highest injury level: Fatal 
Aircraft 1 details
Aircraft manufacturer: Piper Aircraft Corp 
Aircraft model: PA-28 
Aircraft registration: VH-WAS 
Serial number: 28-7505009 
Type of operation: Private 
Damage to aircraft: Substantial 
Departure point:Coolangatta QLD
Departure time:0857
Destination:Coolangatta QLD
Aircraft 2 details
Aircraft manufacturer: Piper Aircraft Corp 
Aircraft model: PA-28 
Aircraft registration: VH-DMB 
Serial number: 28-7405012 
Type of operation: Private 
Damage to aircraft: Destroyed 
Departure point:Surfers Gardens QLD
Departure time:0
Destination:Surfers Gardens QLD
Share this page Provide feedback on this investigation